Already Implemented in Various Countries
Many countries already have front-of-package nutrition labels in various forms. For instance, Chile uses a stop sign symbol to indicate high levels of sugar, saturated fat, sodium, or calories.
Source: Freepik
In Israel, there’s a red warning label for such products, and in Singapore, beverages are graded based on their nutritional value.
Advocates Have Been Waiting Almost 20 Years
For nearly two decades, advocates have urged the FDA to mandate front-of-pack labels, claiming they help people make healthier choices and encourage food manufacturers to improve their recipes.
Source: Depositphotos
The FDA remained mostly silent on this issue until it announced plans to explore front-of-pack labels as part of a national health strategy unveiled at the 2022 White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health.
FDA Performs Research
Since then, the FDA has reviewed research and conducted focus groups to test label designs.
Source: Freepik
However, the proposal faces opposition from trade associations representing the food and beverage industry, which created their own voluntary front-of-package labeling system over a decade ago.
First Amendment Challenges
Some of the FDA’s proposed label designs may also face First Amendment challenges.
Source: Wikimedia
Jennifer Pomeranz, an associate professor at NYU’s School of Global Public Health, noted that factual designs—such as listing grams of added sugars—are more likely to be deemed constitutional compared to interpretive designs with shapes or colors indicating healthiness.
Traffic Light System
The FDA tested various label options, including traffic light colors to indicate high (red), medium (yellow), or low (green) levels of saturated fat, sodium, or added sugars.
Source: Freepik
This included labels indicating if a product is “high in” these nutrients, sometimes with the percentage of the recommended daily value per serving.
FDA yet to Disclose More Information
An FDA spokesperson did not reveal which label design will be used or when the proposed rule will be released, only indicating it is targeted for this summer despite a previous deadline.
Source: @NahBabyNah/X
The Consumer Brands Association and FMI, which created the voluntary Facts up Front label system in 2011, oppose mandatory interpretive designs like the red light/green light system.
Opposition From Other Groups
They argue that such labels may unnecessarily alarm consumers and fail to provide meaningful context about how a food item fits into a healthy diet.
Source: Reddit
Their system highlights up to four key nutrients—calories, saturated fat, sodium, and added sugars—on the front of packages and can include information on beneficial nutrients like potassium or fiber. The association reports that 207,000 products featured Facts up Front as of 2021.
Comprehensive Labeling on All Products
Advocates for mandatory labeling argue that the voluntary system is insufficiently widespread and lacks interpretive context.
Source: Karsten Winegeart/Unsplash
Eva Greenthal from the Center for Science in the Public Interest, which first petitioned the FDA in 2006 for front-of-pack labels, emphasized the need for comprehensive labeling across all products, not just those from participating manufacturers. She also criticized the voluntary labels for not helping consumers interpret the information effectively.
Healthier Consumer Choices
Courtney Gaine, president and CEO of the Sugar Association, supports transparency but questions the effectiveness of mandatory front-of-pack labeling in improving diets.
Source: Freepik
Greenthal and other proponents, however, cite global evidence showing that such labels lead to healthier consumer choices and product reformulations, as seen in Chile since 2016.
Informing Consumers
The FDA’s own review of scientific literature found that front-of-pack labels help consumers identify healthy foods and are particularly beneficial for those with lower nutrition knowledge and busy schedules.
Source: Freepik
This discussion is set against a backdrop of rising obesity rates in the U.S., with obesity affecting about 42% of adults and diet-related diseases causing over a million deaths annually.
Addresses Diet-Related Diseases
Xaq Frohlich, an associate professor at Auburn University, noted that changes to food labels have historically led to industry reformulations, improving food quality even if consumers do not directly read the labels.
Source: Freepik
Greenthal highlighted the importance of front-of-package labeling for various groups, including busy parents and individuals with low nutrition literacy, and stressed the urgency of addressing diet-related chronic diseases through such policies.