Michigan Supreme Court Revives Old Laws Regulating Minimum Wage, Tips, and Sick Leave

By: Stephanie Bontorin | Published: Aug 14, 2024

The Michigan Supreme Court made a landmark decision by voting 4-3 on unconstitutional legislative amendments that changed the way that minimum wage, tip, and paid sick leave are handled in the state.

Change to the minimum wage will go into effect on February 21, 2025, but business owners do not know what specifics will be upheld at that time.

What Changes Were Made in the Past

Back in September 2018, the Michigan legislature adopted new laws as part of a proposed ballot measure instead of allowing residents to vote on the matter.

Advertisement
A clear and detailed view of the front facade of the U.S. Supreme Court, showcasing the neoclassical architecture and the phrase "Equal Justice Under Law" inscribed above the columns.

Source: Wikimedia Commons

The measures were the Earned Sick Time Act (ESTA) and the Improved Workforce Opportunity Wage Act (IWOWA). However, during the legislative season, there were substantive amendments to both of the acts and several legal challenges have followed.

Violating the Constitution

In July of 2022, a Michigan Court of Claims judge noted that the previous legislature amendments violated the state’s constitution.

Advertisement
A woman speaking into a bullhorn surrounded by blue signs that read "stand with workers"

Source: @RevampedCP/X

Another discussion was held in January 2023 by a three-judge panel at the Michigan Court of Appeals, who reserved the decision and upheld the amendments. However, years of litigation later, and six years after the ESTA and IWOWA were originally created, the state supreme court decided that the amendments to be reinstated.

Changes to the Minimum Wage

The main change people are concerned about in the state is the amendment to the minimum wage. The measure initially intended to raise the minimum wage in the state to $10. However, due to the elapsed time, that number will be raised even higher to account for inflation.

Advertisement
A view of a fast-food counter with workers in uniform and face masks preparing orders, with a digital menu screen in the background

Source: Visual Karsa/Unsplash

As of 2025, when the new laws are initiated, the minimum wage will likely exceed $10.56 according to the length of the time and the legislative maneuvers that have been upheld. The minimum wage is currently $7.25 an hour, which does not allow a healthy budget for an adult living alone or with a roommate.

Other Amendments That Will Be Upheld

Two other big changes will come in the state. Specifically, the minimum wage for tipped employees will now be 48% of the minimum wage. Often, servers and bartenders who make healthy tips rely more heavily on that as payment than the minimum wage.

Advertisement
Three men stand behind a busy bar

Source: Taylor Davidson/Unsplash

As well, paid sick leave provisions in the ballot adopted by the legislature in 2018 will become legal again in Michigan to allow employees a specific number of paid sick days a month.

Employers and Employees Have Questions

Although the decisions that were handed down have made several big changes in the state, there are still a few pieces of business that have not yet been settled.

A worker gets her hand stuck in heavy machinery while another employee tries to help get it out

Source: Freepik

Specifically, people want to know what happens to paid sick leave that employers provide or what employees accumulate under the new law. Will the days be wiped out of grandfathered in? As well, many want to know if employers have an application to add more sick leave benefits under the new law in early 2025.

Advertisement

Michigan Lawmakers Respond to the Questions

The Michigan Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity’s Wage & Hour Division responded to several business owners’ questions and comments.

The exterior of a large court house

Source: @MISupremeCourt/X

“The Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity is currently reviewing the court’s decision. We are committed to collaborating with the labor and business communities on educational outreach to ensure a thorough understanding and smooth implementation of the court’s ruling.”

Advertisement

Future Legislative Changes Are Possible

There are some possible complications allowed if the legislator and governor choose to amend the law by a vote.

The exterior of the Florida Supreme Court building

Source: Wikipedia

It’s possible that elected officials might take issue with the revised minimum wage, tip, and paid sick leave standards and attempt to change them before being reinstated next year.

Advertisement

Minimum Wage Adjustments for Inflation

In February of 2025, the Michigan Supreme Court will amend the minimum wage to $10. However, there will also be amendments for inflation in the state.

A man wearing black uses a circular saw on a piece of wood

Source: Greyson Joralemon/Unsplash

Although the wage will increase to $10.65 in February of 2026, it is expected to rise to $12 per hour in February of 2028.

Advertisement

The Wage for Tipped Employees Will Also Rise

In addition to increasing the minimum wage for regular employees, tipped employees will also see their wages rise over time.

Bartender holds a tray with several cocktails

Source: Freepik

By February 2028, the minimum wage for tipped employees will be 90% of the minimum wage. They also expect that it will rise to 100% to adjust for differences in task difficulty.

Advertisement

The Wage Can Vary Based on Different Factors

Although the wage will be rising for a number of employees, there are some exceptions under the new law.

Factory worker ensures everything is up to the correct safety standards

Source: Freepik

Employees who work under a certain number of hours or in specific industries have the ability to make even less than the current minimum wage.

Advertisement