Tennessee Man Has to Pay $1.2 Million After Cutting Down His Neighbors’ Trees While They Were on Vacation
Michael and Emma had moved to a quiet neighborhood near Nashville, Tennessee. They loved their new home, especially the beautiful oak trees that provided privacy and a connection to nature.
Their serene life took an unexpected turn when their neighbor decided to take matters into his own hands.
Purchasing Their Dream Home
When Michael and Emma bought their new home outside Nashville, Tennesse, they were thrilled that it had a completely unique yard lined with gorgeous, giant oak trees that gave them the privacy they were looking for.
However, the yard also contained several mulberry trees that they were less fond of. They planned to eventually cut down the mulberry trees but first wanted to make sure they got a good price from a reliable tree felling company.
Asking Neighbors for Help
Michael decided to ask a few of his neighbors if they knew any trustworthy companies and started getting quotes for the removal of the mulberry trees. That’s when something serendipitous happened.
Michael and Emma’s new neighbor reached out and told them that he owned a tree removal company and would be happy to take on the job of cutting down the unwanted mulberry trees for them.
The Neighbor's Secret Motive
While Michael thought the offer was kind and genuine, the neighbor actually had a secret motive.
He had recently spent quite a good deal of money renovating his back porch, adding a pizza oven and jacuzzi to create a kind of backyard oasis. And Michael’s trees created substantial shade where he wanted sun.
Negotiations Were Still in Progress
After the neighbor originally offered his company to remove the trees, Michael and Emma told him to send them an official quote, and they would decide whether or not to use him for the service.
However, while waiting for that quote, Michael and Emma went away for a few days. When they returned, they were absolutely shocked to see workers in their yard, cutting down not just the mulberry trees but the oak trees too.
A Horrifying Discovery
Michael found his yard in chaos; his cherished oak trees were being cut down without his permission and he couldn’t understand who was doing this and why.
He quickly realized the workers were from his neighbor’s company, and Michael, furious and helpless, demanded they stop immediately. But sadly, it was too late.
Destruction and Despair
The scene was devastating. The once beautiful yard was littered with fallen trees, trampled grass, and uprooted flower beds.
Michael confronted the workers, and they explained that their boss, his neighbor, had told them to cut down all the trees in the yard, including the decades-old oak trees.
Making Matters Even Worse
Of course, Michael and Emma were beside themselves, so they headed into their home to figure out what to do next. There, they found something that was almost as shocking as the ruined yard.
The neighbor had left a $2,000 bill under their door for the tree removal service they never agreed to. But that wasn’t even the end of this torture.
The Police Arrived the Very Next Morning
That night, while Michael and Emma slept, a wild storm hit Nashville and swept the giant felled trees into the road alongside their house.
When they woke up, the police were at their door. They said that because the trees came from Michael and Emma’s yard, they had to pay a fine to the city for their removal from the street.
Michael and Emma Didn't Know What to Do Next
Michael continuously called his neighbor, hoping to understand what happened, but it only went to voicemail. In his frustration, Michael turned to Reddit for advice
He quickly found the “r/treelaw” subreddit thread and realized that his situation was not entirely unique. There was an entire community of people reporting similar scenarios, so Michael decided to add his story, too.
Seeking Justice Online
Michael wrote, “When I returned from vacation last week, I came home to 12 tree stumps, mashed up grass, and a letter telling me to expect a Venmo payment for $2000.”
Luckily, the community responded immediately. Many Reddit users sympathized with his situation, while others provided valuable insights into his rights. Specifcally, the importance of consulting an arborist to assess the damage.
Michael Contacts an Arborist Right Away
Thanks to the advice, Michael decided that he would first reach out to an arborist, or tree doctor, to find out just how much his illegally felled trees were worth.
All trees have a fiscal value which changes depending on the type of tree, as well as its size and age. So Michael wasn’t sure if his trees were worth just a few hundred or several thousand dollars.
The Arborist's Evaluation
An arborist’s assessment revealed the true value of the destroyed trees. Because they were large, old oaks, they were worth even more than Michael and Emma had expected.
Once again, thanks to the advice on Reddit, Michael and Emma contacted a lawyer who specialized in tree law or “arboreal arbitration.” These lawyers understand the value of trees and specifically work on private property destruction disputes.
The Legal Battle Begins
With the arborist’s valuation of the trees in hand and the assistance of the tree law lawyer, Michael and Emma estimated that their neighbor owes them a whopping $1.2 million.
While that may seem like a lot of money, it included the costs of the destroyed trees, legal fees, and the city council’s cleanup bill for the road obstructed by the fallen trees.
The Judge Ruled Against the Neighbor
After hearing both sides of the case, the judge in Tennessee ruled in Michael and Emma’s favor and sentenced their neighbor to pay the entire $1.2 million fine they had requested.
Like most Americans, the neighbor didn’t have over a million dollars just lying around. His egregious and illegal mistake of cutting down Michael’s trees without permission lost him everything.
The Neighbor's Downfall
The neighbor’s tree felling business went bankrupt after the lawsuit, and in order to pay the fine, he was forced to sell his home and move to a more affordable neighborhood.
While this may seem harsh, it certainly is an important lesson for everyone and anyone: You absolutely cannot cut down trees on another person’s property without their permission, otherwise, you will pay the consequences.
Community Support
Another interesting aspect of this story is the widespread support and advice from the online Reddit community. In truth, Michael couldn’t have won his case without them.
People empathized with his situation and shared similar stories, but it was their advice that led Michael and Emma first to an arborist and then to a lawyer who specialized in tree law.
Lessons Learned
There’s no doubt that neither Michael nor his neighbor will ever forget this tragic tale, but it’s also important that anyone who reads it learns it.
This incident highlights the importance of understanding property and tree laws on both sides of the fence. For those on the receiving end, the biggest lesson is that consulting experts and seeking legal advice can make a significant difference when dealing with disputes.
A Sweet Victory for Michael and Emma
Michael updated his Reddit followers, expressing gratitude for their support. He shared the good news that they would be replanting all 12 oak trees at no cost to themselves.
The ordeal was a tough lesson, but it ended on a positive note with a restored yard and a stronger community bond.
Michael and Emma's Case Is Not Unique
The Reddit subthread proves that disputes between neighbors regarding trees and tree removal are extremely common. However, most situations don’t end in a $1 million fine.
But some do; in fact, one man from New Jersey was forced to pay $1 million for cutting down hundreds of trees on his neighbor’s property.
New Jersey Man Forced to Pay $1 Million After Felling Over 200 Trees
In 2011, Jay Patel of Mahwah, New Jersey, faced similar consequences after cutting down 221 trees on his neighbor’s property to improve his view of the nearby Rampapo Mountains.
The property owners, the Cantows, were absolutely shocked by the damage, and like Michael and Emma, immediately reached out to an arborist to assess the value of the damage.
Taking the Case to Court
When the Cantows realized that nearly $1 million worth of trees had been cut down, they took their case to court. There, Patel and his lawyers argued that it wasn’t actually Patel’s fault but that of the company because they cut down more trees than he requested.
Patel also claimed that they only removed 54 trees on the Cantows’ property, as the rest were actually behind his boundary line.
The Court Sided With the Cantows
Once again, the court sided with the property owners, the Cantows, who had lost nearly $1 million worth of trees due to Patel’s mistake.
But unlike Michael’s neighbor, Patel actually had $1 million to pay the fine as he was a multi-millionaire who owned several Dunkin Donuts franchises.
This Story Is an Important Lesson for Everyone
Even though he had $1 million to pay the fine, no one wants to find themselves in a situation like this one.
Therefore, it’s crucial to understand that if you cut down any trees on someone else’s property, you will pay the consequences, and they will likely be very expensive.