Nurse Accused of Swapped Patients’ Fentanyl With Water, Leading to $303 Million Lawsuit Against Oregon Hospital

By: May Man Published: Sep 10, 2024

A total of eighteen patients—nine survivors and the families of nine deceased individuals—are now at the center of a $303 million lawsuit against an Oregon hospital.

The lawsuit is rooted in allegations that a nurse engaged in a dangerous scheme, where fentanyl was replaced with bacteria-contaminated water in intravenous (IV) drips.

Outrage Over Alleged Medical Misconduct

This alleged misconduct has not only shocked the community but has also ignited public and legal outrage.

Advertisement
Hospital corridor with wheelchair in the middle

Source: Freepik

The implications of such actions are severe, as they have resulted in the deterioration of several patients’ health, some fatally.

Nurse Arrested and Charged

The accused nurse, Dani Marie Schofield, 36, was employed at Asante Rogue Regional Medical Center in Medford, Oregon.

Advertisement
This image shows a nurse adjusting a person’s IV medication. The person is partially visible

Source: Freepik

She was arrested in June after an investigation into the hospital’s handling of controlled substances. Schofield now faces 44 counts of second-degree assault, all tied to the misuse of drugs and resulting infections among patients.

Details of the Investigation

Authorities have indicated that the charges followed a comprehensive police investigation. The probe revealed that controlled substances had been misappropriated and tampered with, leading to the infections.

Advertisement
A woman standing in front of a board during an investigation

Source: Freepik

Despite the severity of the charges, Schofield has pleaded not guilty to all allegations brought against her.

Schofield’s Response to the Allegations

In response to the accusations, Schofield maintained her belief in the legal process. She told The Lund Report, “The Truth will, I’m sure, come out,” expressing confidence that her side of the story would eventually be revealed.

Advertisement
Lawsuit paperwork next to a book and a pen

Source: Adobe Stock

Nevertheless, she resigned from her position about a month after the initial charges were filed.

Hospital Accused of Negligence

The $303 million lawsuit primarily targets the hospital, accusing it of negligence and medical malpractice. The plaintiffs argue that had proper safety protocols been followed, the nurse would not have had the opportunity to steal and tamper with the drugs.

The interior of a hospital room with a row of beds

Source: Gilberto Olimpio/Unsplash

Curiously, Schofield herself is not named as a defendant in this lawsuit.

Advertisement

Additional Lawsuit Involving Horace Wilson’s Death

In addition to the main suit, a separate $11.5 million lawsuit was filed earlier this year. This case involves the estate of Horace Wilson, a 65-year-old man who died after developing multi-organ failure due to sepsis.

A close-up photograph of the hand of a hospital patient with an IV

Source: iStock

The lawsuit claims Wilson’s infection stemmed from bacteria-laden water introduced into his bloodstream through his IV drip.

Advertisement

Details of Wilson’s Infection and Death

According to The Daily Mail, Wilson was admitted to the hospital for a spleen removal following an accident. However, his condition rapidly worsened after contracting the infection.

Close-Up Photo of a Doctor in White Coat

Source: RDNE Stock project/Pexels

The source of the infection was identified as staphylococcus epidermidis, a bacterium commonly associated with waterborne contamination.

Advertisement

Hospital Declines to Comment

Despite the seriousness of these allegations, the hospital has refrained from commenting publicly on the matter.

A hospital bed in a room near a window.

Source: Saulo Zayas/Pexels

A spokesperson for the facility declined to provide any statement regarding the legal proceedings or the claims made against them.

Advertisement

Hospital Notifies Claimants of Fentanyl Substitution

According to the lawsuit, the hospital began informing claimants in December about the substitution of fentanyl with tap water, which caused bacterial infections.

A person lays in a hospital bed with an IV hooked up to their hand

Source: Stepen Andrews/Unsplash

The formal complaint notes, “All Plaintiff Patients were infected with bacterium uniquely associated with waterborne transmission.”

Advertisement

Plaintiffs Seek Damages for Mental and Physical Suffering

The plaintiffs, many of whom are still grappling with the aftermath of the infections, are seeking compensation for various damages.

A brown wooden judge’s gavel on a white surface.

Source: Tingey Injury Law Firm/Unsplash

These include medical expenses, lost income, mental anguish, and, in cases where patients died, the pain and suffering experienced by their families.

Advertisement

Police Investigation and the Importance of Protocols

Medford police launched an investigation into the hospital late last year after officials reported a rise in central line infections between July 2022 and July 2023.

The side of a white police car on the streets of a big city

Source: Matt Popovich/Unsplash

The hospital suspected that the spike in infections was linked to an employee diverting fentanyl, highlighting the need for stricter protocols to prevent theft.

Advertisement