America’s Concerns With TikTok
TikTok is run by ByteDance, which is based in China. Therefore, many Americans worry that the Chinese government could gain access to the data the social media platform collects and use it to send subliminal political messaging to Americans.
Source: Reddit
This has become such a pressing concern that President Joe Biden signed a bill in April 2024 that requires ByteDance to either sell TikTok to a U.S. company or face being banned throughout the entire country.
Biden’s Law Forces Google and Apple to Remove TikTok from App Stores
Within his bill, Biden also specified that the two major smartphone manufacturers, Google and Apple, had to remove TikTok from their app store within 270 days if ByteDance doesn’t sell.
Source: Shutterstock
However, neither company has removed the social media app yet. And they may not have to, as ByteDance has promised to fight the president’s legislation in court this year.
ByteDance Claims the Bill Violated Their First Amendment Rights
The Chinese company has publicly stated that President Biden’s bill forcing ByteDance to sell TikTok to an American company or be banned throughout the country is completely unconstitutional.
Source: Shutterstock
The argument is that, by banning TikTok solely because it is based in China, the U.S. government would not be violating the rights of the company but the more than 148 million American users. They deserve to use the app at their discretion, as is their First Amendment right.
The U.S. Government Will Argue TikTok Is a Threat to National Security
Of course, the U.S. government is prepared to sue over the president’s bill. They will argue that while technically the ban may violate First Amendment rights, it is within their power to do so, as the social media app is a direct threat to national security.
Source: Freepik
An annotation within the First Amendment reads, “Preservation of the security of the Nation from its enemies, foreign and domestic, is the obligation of government and one of the foremost reasons for government to exist. Pursuit of this goal may lead government officials at times to trespass in areas protected by the guarantees of speech and press and may require the balancing away of rights that might be preserved inviolate at other times.”
TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew’s Congressional Hearing
For TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew, the court case against Biden’s bill will be just another in a long line of interactions turned altercations with the U.S. government.
Source: @CBSNews/YouTube
Shou Chew has gone before Congress several times over the past couple of years. In January 2024, they spent hours grilling the CEO regarding his citizenship and connections to the Communist Party of China.
TikTok CEO Shou Chew Claims He Has No Affiliation With the CCP
Since the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949, the country’s government has been run exclusively by members of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
Source: Depositphotos
However, many Chinese citizens do not support the CCP, and even millions more who do do not have a direct connection to anyone in power. TikTok CEO Shou Chew claims that not only does he not have any personal connection with the party, but he’s also not even a Chinese citizen. He is from Singapore.
Border Patrol Agents Are Now Asking TikTok Employees the Same Questions
After the transcript of the congressional hearing was made public, many people were shocked at just how relentless Congress was in questioning the CEO’s citizenship and connections to the CCP.
Source: Reddit
But now it turns out that Shou Chew isn’t the only member of the TikTok team having to defend himself from American authorities. Border patrol agents have been asking almost identical questions to any TikTok employee entering the United States.
30 ByteDance Employees Have Been Interrogated
According to an article published by Forbes on April 30, 2024, more than 30 TikTok and ByteDance employees have been stopped at the border and questioned by Congress, just as Shou Chew was.
Source: Homeland Security
The questions are mostly related to their citizenships and connections to the CCP, as well as their specific access to U.S. TikToker’s personal data, where the data centers are, and if they are involved in Project Texas.
ByteDance Claims No US Data Is Held in China
There have been no reports of concerning answers from the TikTok and ByteDance employees questioned at the border. In fact, each and every one of them, including Shou Chew and other executives, all corroborate that neither they nor the company are connected in any way to the CCP.
Source: Shutterstock
However, Forbes did report that collected TikTok data had been found in China, even though CEO Shou Chew said during his congressional testimony in March 2023, “American data has always been stored in Virginia and Singapore.”
Will the Presidential Election Change the TikTok Ban?
With the US presidential election only a few months away, many Americans are wondering whether or not the TikTok ban will be overturned in November. Clearly, President Biden is for the ban, as he signed the bill into law. However, if former President Donald Trump takes back the Oval Office, he may choose to eliminate the legislation.
Source: @WashingtonPost/YouTube
Trump originally supported the banning of the Chinese-based app, but he recently reversed his position. As of March 2024, Trump says he is against Biden’s bill and for TikTok, though that opinion could change again.
Will TikTok Be Banned in the U.S.?
Whether or not TikTok will actually be banned in the United States depends on a wide variety of factors. From the decision of the courts after ByteDance fights back to who wins the presidency in November, and even if TikTok does decide to sell to a U.S. company, there are far too many “ifs” to guess the future of the popular app.
Source: Depositphotos
But one thing is for sure: all TikTok and ByteDance employees, not just the executives, should be fully prepared to answer detailed questions about their personal lives, their jobs and the CCP by U.S. authorities until this situation is resolved.