In Defense of the New Rule
Gov. Landry quickly came to the defense of his new law after being heavily criticised and sued by parents around the state.
Source: Freepik
He declared that the state would put up a fight against the lawsuits, which claimed that posting the Ten Commandments in schools in unconstitutional.
Arguments From Parents
Parents in the state have brought up the separation of church and state is baked into the constitution and declares that all government entities not favor one religion over the other.
Source: Freepik
Also, there are other groups of religious minorities, including Jewish, Unitarian, Universalist, and Muslim, who claim that the rule “substantially interferes with and burdens” their rights to raise their chicken with their chosen religion.
Bipartisan Support
Although there has been massive pushback, both on the internet and within the state court system, Landy has said that he has definitive bipartisan support across the aisle in the Louisiana legislature.
Source: @DanClaitor/X
He also remarked, “I don’t see what the whole big fuss is about.”
What Schools Are Complying
The current status of schools complying with the law varies across the state.
Source: Rubén Rodriguez/Unsplash
As of now, Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill says that as of this Monday, she is not aware of any schools that have complied with the mandate. The law will take place in January.
Legal Proceedings
Parents suing the school district for violating their First Amendment rights have actually had some success in stopping the bill from passing.
Unsplash user Adam Michael Szuscik
A judge agreed to halt the law until November 15. Even a small postponement in the rule could fundamentally alter the law’s requirements.
How the State Will Respond
The state plans to issue a motion of dismissal against the case. In many instances, a judge will use their discretion to determine if a lawsuit is frivolous or not.
Source: Freepik
A separate legal strategy that Louisiana could employ describes how the law can be applied to meet legal, and constitutional requirements. This might include only displaying the Ten Commandments in classrooms where all the parents agree.
Posting the Ten Commandments in Different Ways
Another way that the school system could get around the lawsuit is by adding the Ten Commandments to different posters.
Source: CDC/Unsplash
For example, state lawmakers who want to keep the law pushed forward say that they could include the post design based on the founding fathers, Martin Luther King Jr. or Moses.
Legal Precedent
Lawsuits are usually decided on other precedents decided in the state. In this case, the families are able to successfully sue the school system based on a similar Supreme Court case from 1980.
Source: Ian Hutchinson/Unsplash
In this case, the Supreme Court struck down a Kentucky law that required schools to post the Ten Commandments in public classrooms. The court system decided it goes against church and state separation.
Violating the First Amendment
Many parents share concerns that the decision to add the religious doctrine into schools directly violates their First Amendment rights.
Source: Wikipedia Commons
In 1980, the Supreme Court noted a similar cause for striking down the inclusion of the Ten Commandments in school classrooms.
Argument for Historical Relevance
Many proponents of the law have described its historical relevance as a reason for including the Ten Commandments in schools.
Source: Maarten Brakkee/Unsplash
If this is the case, then students should feel free to study them as part of a world religions or history course instead of being an assumed part of the general culture of the classroom.